Red Hook Community Justice Center

Overview

Launched in June 2000, the Red Hook Community Justice Center is the nation's first multi-jurisdictional community court. Operating out of a refurbished Catholic school in the heart of a geographically and socially isolated neighborhood in southwest Brooklyn, the Justice Center seeks to solve neighborhood problems using a coordinated response. At Red Hook, a single judge hears neighborhood cases from three police precincts (covering approximately 200,000 people) that under ordinary circumstances would go to three different courts—Civil, Family, and Criminal.

The Red Hook judge has an array of sanctions and services at his disposal. These include community restitution projects, short-term psychoeducational groups, and long-term treatment (e.g., drug treatment, mental health treatment, and trauma-focused psychotherapy). Red Hook features an on-site clinic staffed by social service professionals who use trauma- and evidence-informed approaches to assess and connect individuals to appropriate services. The Justice Center also works to connect court-involved youth to strengths-based programming, including art projects and peer education programs.

The Red Hook story extends far beyond what happens in the courtroom. The courthouse is the hub for an array of unconventional programs that contribute to reducing fear and improving public trust in government. These include mediation, community service and a youth court where teenagers are trained to resolve actual cases involving their peers. The Center also has a housing resource center, which provides support and information to residents with cases in housing court, and an AmeriCorps program, the New York Juvenile Justice Corps.

How It Works

A formerly vacant Catholic school serves as the home for the Red Hook Community Justice Center.A formerly vacant Catholic school serves as the home for the Red Hook Community Justice Center.Key features of the Justice Center include:

Coordination: The Justice Center handles low-level criminal cases (including some felonies), as well as selected Family Court and Civil Court matters. In hearing these cases, the Justice Center recognizes that neighborhood problems do not conform to the arbitrary jurisdictional boundaries of the modern court system. By having a single judge handle matters that ordinarily are heard by different decision makers at different locations, Red Hook offers a swifter and more coordinated judicial response.

Restitution: By mandating offenders to restore the community, the Justice Center makes justice more visible to local residents and acknowledges that communities can be victims just like individuals. Restitution projects include painting over graffiti, sweeping the streets and cleaning the Justice Center.

Help: By linking defendants to drug treatment and by providing on-site services, the Justice Center seeks to strengthen families and help individuals avoid further involvement with the court system. Services are not limited to court users but are available to anyone in the community wishing to avail themselves of them.

Accountability: Compliance with social service and community restitution sanctions is rigorously monitored by the Red Hook judge, who requires litigants to return to court frequently to report on their progress and to submit urine tests. State-of-the-art technology helps ensure accountability.

Prevention: The Justice Center actively seeks to resolve local problems before they become court cases. The Justice Center's prevention programs include community mediation and a youth court that offers intensive leadership training to local teenagers.

To view more photos of the Red Hook Community Justice Center from the American Institute of Architects, click here.

Results

Reduced Incarceration: The Justice Center has reduced the use of jail at arraignment in misdemeanor cases by 50 percent.

Accountability: Compliance rates with court orders average 75 percent–a 50 percent improvement on the standard at comparable courts.

Public Trust: Approval ratings of police, prosecutors and judges have increased three‑fold since the Justice Center opened. 

Public Support: A door-to-door survey revealed that 94 percent of local residents support the community court. Before the Justice Center opened, only 12 percent of local residents rated local courts favorably. 

Reduced Fear: Since 1999, the percentage of Red Hook residents who say they are afraid to go to the parks or subway at night has dropped 42 percent.

Fairness: More than 85 percent of criminal defendants report that their cases were handled fairly by the Justice Center–results that were consistent regardless of defendant background (e.g. race, sex, education) or case outcome.

Click here to read more about research results, including caseload, sentencing, compliance, and other outcomes. Click here for an independent evaluation of the Justice Center completed by the National Center for State Courts in 2013.

Partners

The Justice Center is the product of a unique public-private partnership that has engaged all levels of government—county, city, state, and federal. Planning, which was led by the Center for Court Innovation in concert with the Kings County District Attorney's Office, was underwritten by the U.S. Department of Justice. Core operational funding is provided by the New York State Unified Court System and the City of New York. A variety of government and private funders also provide ongoing support. 

The Justice Center's model of public-private partnership extends beyond funding—it relies on an array of institutional partners to identify local problems, supervise community service, and offer social services. These include:

Featured Research

Articles

Praising Red Hook Justice Center’s Approach to Public Safety, Mayor-Elect de Blasio Names Bratton as Police Commissioner

Praising Red Hook Justice Center’s Approach to Public Safety, Mayor-Elect de Blasio Names Bratton as Police Commissioner

BROOKLYN, N.Y., DEC. 5, 2013—Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio chose the Red Hook Community Justice Center as the setting for one of the first major appointments of his administration: William Bratton as police commissioner.

In his remarks, the incoming mayor made clear why he’d chosen the Justice Center to make the announcement: he, Bratton, and the Justice Center all share a belief in the importance of community collaboration.

Reporters are eager to ask questions after Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio names William Bratton as police commissioner.Reporters are eager to ask questions after Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio names William Bratton as police commissioner.

Read More

Publications

A Community Court Grows in Brooklyn: A Comprehensive Evaluation of the Red Hook Community Justice Center (Full Report)

A Community Court Grows in Brooklyn: A Comprehensive Evaluation of the Red Hook Community Justice Center (Full Report)

By Cynthia G. Lee, Fred L. Cheesman II, David Rottman, Rachel Swaner, Suvi Hynynen Lambson, Michael Rempel and Richard Curtis

With funding from the National Institute of Justice, the National Center for State Courts completed this independent evaluation of the Red Hook Community Justice Center in 2013. The evaluation found that the Justice Center's emphasis on alternatives to incarceration, including community restitution projects and social services, helped reduce the use of jail even as it helped reduce recidivism among misdemeanor offenders.

 

Download executive summary

Download a fact sheet about the evaluation

Listen to an interview with the researchers

Download a fact sheet highlighting recommendations for improving court responses to misdemeanors

Publications

The Adolescent Diversion Program

The Adolescent Diversion Program

By Michael Rempel, Suvi Hynynen Lambson, Carolyn R. Cadoret and Allyson Walker Franklin

This report examines the first six months of the pilot Adolescent Diversion Program for court involved 16 and 17 year-olds at nine sites in New York State. The study found that diverting these youth to services does not increase recidivism rates and, in fact, reduces recidivism for those who would otherwise pose the greatest risk to public safety.

Read a summary of the study

Listen to an interview with the researchers

Red Hook Community Justice Blogs
  • March 24, 2014
    Vote for the Justice Center!

    Want to help make a difference? We're participating in the 4th annual 'IKEA Life Improvement Challenge' - a program that gives the Red Hook...

    Read More
  • March 18, 2014
    Youth Summer Internship and Job Fair

    Are you between the ages of 14 and 21 and don't have any plans for the summer? Are you interested in building your resume and making extra...

    Read More
  • March 17, 2014
    Free Basketball Training Program in Red Hook

    Teens don't miss out on this new free basketball training program every Friday at the Miccio Center in Red Hook. Learn from the professionals. Boys...

    Read More
Contact
  • New York
  • 520 8th Avenue
  • 18th Floor
  • New York, NY 10018
  • phone: 646.386.3100
  • Syracuse
  • One Park Place
  • 300 South State Street
  • Syracuse, NY 13202
  • phone: 315.266.4330
  • London
  • Kean House, 6 Kean Street
  • London, WC2B 4AS
  • phone: +44 2076.329.060